I.A.Y.

Youth Update Masthead

A publication of the Institute for the study of
Antisocial behaviour in Youth (IAY).
Affiliated with the
Centre for Addiction and Mental Health and The Hospital for Sick Children

Edited by Dr. Jalal Shamsie,
MB, FRCP(C)
Director, Institute for the study of Antisocial behaviour in Youth
Professor of Psychiatry, University of Toronto

Volume 18 Number 3 Winter 2000

In this Issue:

Special Feature:

Special Feature: Bullying in the School Setting: A Legal or an Educational Approach
by
Martha Mackinnon and Andrea Monahan

Online Extra: References for this Issue*

HomeAbout the I.A.Y.
Publications
Price List
Books
Flyers
Youth Update Subscriptions
Order Form
Seminars
Video Library
* References were not inlcuded in the print version due to space limitations.
 

Also in this Issue:

Predicting Violent Behaviour in Youth to top

Borum, R. (2000). Assessing violence risk among youth. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 56:10, 1263-1288.

Although the rate of serious violent crime has been declining because of high profile school shootings, there is a need and a demand to identify youth that are at risk of becoming violent.

There has been a great deal of research done to determine risk factors for aggression and violence in children and adolescents. These factors can be classified into three categories:

Historical Factors

  • School Problems: these include truancy, and academic failure.
  • Victim of maltreatment or abuse: physical or sexual abuse, neglect.
  • Family maladjustment: family conflict, parental criminality and poor bonding with the family.

Clinical Factors

  • Substance abuse
  • Risk taking and impulsivity
  • Negative attitudes: lack of empathy, remorse and attributing aggression.

Contextual Factors

  • Negative peer relations: gang involvement and delinquent peers.
  • Poor parental management: extreme or inconsistent discipline.
  • Neighbourhood crime
  • Lack of social support
  • Stress and losses

The author states the following principles, which should be used in conducting risk assessment of youth for violence:

  1. Assessment should be systematic and in accordance with some structured or guided scheme.

  2. There should be a detailed inquiry into the history of violence.

  3. Base rates and the age of onset of violence should be considered. Base rate refers to the known prevalence of a specified type of violent behaviour, within a given population, over a given period of time. It is important because some rates may be very high and therefore the act may not be as serious when the base rate is taken into account. For example, in a national survey of high school students in the United States, 46% of boys reported being in a physical fight one or more times in the past 12 months. The age of onset is important, as violent behaviour is more likely to continue into adulthood if it starts before age 11 than if it starts in adolescence.

  4. It is important to determine patterns and precipitants in past acts of violence and to determine whether there is an increase or decrease in the severity or the frequency of violent acts and the factors associated to these changes.

  5. Situational factors are important and include people perceived to be stressful by the youth such as; family, peers, or any specific type of individual or group.

  6. It is advised to receive a consultation if the situation allows it.

Factors Contributing to Bullying to top

Espelage, D.L., Bosworth, K., & Simon, T.R. (2000). Examining the social context of bullying behaviour in early adolescence. Journal of Counseling and Development, 78:3, 326-333.

This study was carried out in a large middle school, 558 students participated. Students were given a questionnaire to complete at midyear. This study examined the social factors that contribute to the development of bullying during early adolescence. Social factors examined included family and adult influences, peer influences, neighbourhood and school safety concerns, economic status and access to guns.

Bullying is defined as a set of behaviours that are intentional and cause physical and psychological harm to others. It includes behaviours such as name-calling, teasing, social exclusion and hitting.

Results

  1. 80.5% of male and female students reported bullying their peers in the past month.

  2. The use of physical discipline by the parents was associated with bullying.

  3. Those who had friends who indulge in antisocial and illegal activities were more likely to bully.

  4. Those who were concerned about safety in the neighbourhood and were more exposed to violence were more likely to bully.

  5. Those who had access to guns were more likely to bully and surprisingly 24.2% reported that they can get a gun very easily.

  6. Those students who spent time with adults who were against violent and aggressive behaviour and suggested non-violent ways of dealing with conflict were less likely to indulge in bullying.

  7. Students who spent more time with adults were less likely to bully.

Conclusions

Parents and their behaviour and attitudes influence bullying behaviour in their children. The friends the child has influence bullying behaviour. The neighbourhood and exposure to violence influences bullying. Authors suggest that bullying should be seen as a behaviour, which occurs in varying degrees in the majority of children rather than focusing on simply identifying the "bullies." They suggest that school counsellors, in efforts to reduce bullying, should include interventions aimed at parents, peers and social factors including the neighbourhood.

.to top

References

  1. A.S.A.P.: A School-based Anti-Violence Program, revised 2nd ed.,available at www.yrbe.edu.on.ca/~safeschl/bullying1.htm or through the London Family Court Clinic

  2. Education Act, R.S.O. 1990, c.E.2, s.23(1)

  3. Ibid., s.23(3)

  4. A principal may suspend a student for up to 20 school days. There is no fixed end to an expulsion; however, an expelled student may apply for re-admission. Many school boards in the Greater Toronto Area will not consider an application for re-admission for one to two years after expulsion.

  5. Education Act, supra, s.265(a)(j)(m)

  6. Operation of Schools Regulation, R.R.O. 1990, Reg.298, as amended, s.11(30(e)(f)

  7. Legal fairness in administrative law is a complex concept that cannot
    be described in detail in this article.

  8. E.Eron, Psychology Today, September, 1995

  9. G.Lajoie, A.McLellan, and C.Seddon, Take Action Against Bullying, www.bullybeware.com to top
Links
Search

IAY Site Map
 

Home | About the IAY | Publications | Seminars | Video Library | Links

Order FormPDF Order Form

If you would like to order your own copy of any IAY publication, please print out and complete the linked form and fax or mail it to the above address. VISA, MasterCard, and cheques are accepted. Cheques should be made payable to IAY/CAMH

Affiliated with the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health and The Hospital for Sick Children

Institute for the study of Antisocial behaviour in Youth (lAY)
Kinark Child and Family Services

475 Iroquois Shore Road
Oakville, ON L6H 1M3
Tel.: (905) 844-4110 ext. 2202; Fax: (905) 844-2996

        

CAMH  Sick Kids



This page was last updated on Sunday, February 20, 2000 1:49 PM